$B$J$s$G$b#2(B$B!"(BHTML$B$N=q$-J}(B$B!"(B$B;HMQ>e$NCm0U(B$B!"(B$B%j%s%/=8(B$B!"(B$B%[!<%`(B

$B9uLZ$N$J$s$G$b7G<(HD(B (0029)

$B5-;v$r=q$/(B$B!"(B$B;~9o=g(B$B!"(B$B%9%l%C%I(B$B!"(B$B8!:w(B$B!"(B$B2a5n%m%0(B$B!"(B$B:G6a$N5-;v(B

$B3F5-;v$N(B Id $B%X%C%@!<9T$N(B # $B$+$i;O$^$kJ8;zNs$r%/%j%C%/$9$k$H!"$=$N5-;v<+?H$K%8%c%s%W$7$^$9!#$=$N5-;v<+?H$N(B URL $B$rCN$j$?$$>l9g$KMxMQ$7$F2<$5$$!#$5$i$K!"3g8L$NCf$N(B reply $B$r%/%j%C%/$9$k$H$=$N5-;v$KJV;v$r=q$/$3$H$,$G$-!"(B thread $B$r%/%j%C%/$9$k$H$=$N5-;v$rCf?4$H$7$?%9%l%C%I7A<0$NL\

Id: #a19981126085935$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 26 08:59:35 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981126002531
Name: $B%-%`%A%,!<%k!w%/%i%i(B
Subject: $B$*$O$h$&$0$k$H!*!*!*!*!*!*(B

$B$K$c$s$@$H! $B%/%i%l%?!<$&$1$H$C$F$/$l$?$N$M$'!)!*!)!*!)!*(B

$B$K$c$s$K$c$s"v(B

$B%/%i%i$N1`$X$d$U$3$=!A!#(B
$B$2$s!"$J$s$FEj9F $BC/$@$+$o$+$i$J$+$C$?$h!0!0!((B

$B$2$s$A$c$s$N4i $B4i $B$^$?%/%i%i$,@j$C$F$"$2$k$+$i!#(B
$B!V;`Aj$,$_$($F$^$9!W$H$+!J>P!K(B

$B8<$A$c$s$O!"%/%i%i$N%$%a!<%8$G$O(B
$BElKLBg$N65 $BElKLBg$G$b!"D9O7$H$7$F07$o$l$F$$$k$H;W$C$F$?$N$@!*(B

$B$&!<$`!&!&!&(B

$B$=$7$F:#F|$,%a%S%&%9$N%i%9%H!#(B

$B%1%m%l%?!<$O!"%1%m%1%m$7$F$+$iIu0u$7$F$M(B
Id: #a19981126010321$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 26 01:03:21 1998
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: Deconstruction in a 'thinking' science

$BK:$l$J$$$?$a$N%a%b!#(B

Referer $B$N5-O?$r$?$I$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"6vA38+IU$1$?$N$@!#(B Sokal $B;a$N%Q%m%G%#!$B$N:G8e$NJ8$G(B refer $B$5$l$F$$$k(B Social Study of Science $B$K=P$?O@J8$,!";d$b8+$?3P$($,$"$k(B Bouwknegt $B$?$A$NO@J8$K4X78$7$F$$$?$N$G!"$S$C$/$j!#6=L#$N$"$kF16H

Social Study of Science $B$K=P$?O@J8$N%W%l%W%j%s%HHG!'(B

Martina Merz and Karin Knorr Cetina, Deconstruction in a 'thinking' science: Theoretical physicists at work, Social Studies of Science 27 (1997) 73-111.

Scanned images $B$N(B Level 2 PS $B$N(B gzipped file $B$NBg$-$5$O(B 800KB $BDxEY$G$9!#(B (Level 1 $B$@$H(B 1.4MB $BDxEY!#(B)

$B$=$3$G%M%?$K$5$l$F$$$k(B Bouwknegt $B$?$A$N8&5f!'(B

P. Bouwknegt, J. McCarthy and K. Pilch, Semi-infinite cohomology of W-algebras, Lett. Math. Phys. 29 (1993) 91.

Id: #a19981126002531$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 26 00:25:31 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981125205322
Name: $B$/$m$-!w#5#0Be$N$*$C$5$s(B($B$K8+$($?$i$7$$(B(;_;))
Subject: Re: $B%1%m%l%?!<(B

$B$o$?$J$Y$5$s[)$/!"!V$$$-$J$j(B$B%-%`%A!*(B$B$H$O8@$o$J$+$C$?$J!W(B

$B$H$$$&$o$1$G!"!V$A!<$C$9!*(B $B%/%i%i$G$9!%%+%(%k(B($B$O$!$H(B) $B%1%m%1%m(B $B%A%c%*(B($B$O$!$H(B)$B!W$C$F$N$r

P.S. $B$J$s$G26$,!V#5#0Be!W$J$N$K!"3{$5$s$O!V#3#1:P$N


Id: #a19981125205322$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Wed Nov 25 20:53:22 1998
URL: watanabe@tohoku.ac.jp
Name: $B$o$?$J$Y!w%Q%7%j(B
Subject: $B%1%m%l%?!<(B
$B:#F|9uLZ$5$s$,8=$l$?$N$G!"%/%i%i$5$s$N%i%V%l%?!<$rEO$7$^$7$?!#(B

$B$D$$$G$K!"%+%m!<%iE9%+%(%k@k8@$N9-9p$r8+$D$1$?$N$G@Z$jH4$$$F(B
$B$*$$$?$s$@$1$I!"$3$l!"$I$&$7$h$&$+!#(B

Id: #a19981125165600$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Wed Nov 25 16:56:00 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981125140555
URL: samaki@hs.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Name: $B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $B$*$9$.$K<:Ni$@$>(B(^^)
$B!!$3$NA0!":49b?.$H$*$9$.$NBPCLK\$rFI$s$@$s$@$1$I!"$*$9$.$O1T$$$H$3$m$,(B
$BB?$$$G$9$h!#(B
$B!!$*$9$.$N$[$&$,@iG\$$$$$C$9!#(B

$B!tJL$NOCBj!!(B
$B!!F|;~!'(B11/28($BEZ!K!"(B18:00
$B!!=89g!'El5~1X!!6d$NNk9->l(B
$B!!$G!"Bg:e$N;3EDA1=U$5$s$,Mh$F0{$_2q$d$k$s$@$1$I!"$$$+$,!)(B
$B!t:#F|$O!"F$N65:`2=!W$J$kO@J8$r=q$$$F$$(B
$B!!$^$7$?!#(B

Id: #a19981125140555$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Wed Nov 25 14:05:55 1998
Name: $B;~ED!!@a(B
Subject: $B2q
$B!X%G%#%i%C%/:nMQAG$N;X?tDjM}!Y$NESCf$rHt$P$7!"(B236$B%Z!<%8$r%+%s%K%s%0$9$k$H!"%,%&%9%\%M!"Id9fDjM}!"%j!<%^%s%m%C%[$r%G%#%i%C%/:nMQAG$GAm3g$9$kLsB+$O2L$?$5$l$F$$$^$9$,!"%I%k%\!<$NDjM}!"AX78?t%3%[%b%m%8! $B$G$b%?%$%_%s%0$N$$$$$3$H$K!"$3$l$i$OA4It>.NS><<7$5$s$N=PHG$[$d$[$d$NJ#AG4v2?(B1,2$B!J4dGH9V:B8=Be$N?t3X!K$G$9$4$/?F@Z$K2r@b$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B%I%k%\!<$NDjM}$O%I%i%`$NDjM}$N%"%J%m%8!<$@$,!"%]%"%s%+%l$NJdBj$K$"$?$k%I%k%\!<$NJdBj$+$i$7$FFq$7$$!#$G$b>.NS$5$s$OZL@$r$d$5$7$/$7$F$/$l$?$j!#(B
$B$^$"!"%^%>$N?M$O!"KY@n$5$s$NJ#AGBe?t4v2?$,$h$m$7$$$N$G$O!#(B
$B$=$l$+$i!">.NS$5$s$O;X?tDjM}$NF~Lg$H$7$F(B1$B$N(Bp.84$B$N5SCm$G!"(BShanahan$B$N%l%/%A%c!<%N!<%H(B638$B$rA&$a$F$k!#!J$3$l$O8+$?$3$H$,$"$j$^$;$s!K!#(B
$B5U$K>.NS$5$s$NFI$_
$BH,LZMM!!%K%+%i%0%"!!$K(B5000$B1_%+%s%Q$7$F$-$^$7$?!#2q
$B:84,MM!!%9%^%$%k7/$C$F4i$D$-$b$$$C$F$k$3$H$N%l%Y%k$b$*$9$.$@$+%T!<%3$K;w$F$$$^$;$s!#$=$NE@!"0K@*ED$5$s$NLLKF$O%_%M%k%P$N$U$/$m$&$N$h$&$G3N$+$K!X$"$d$7$$!Y!#(Bkeijiban/x$B$G!!$I$3$^$GB3$/$L$+$k$_$>!"1+9_$j$7$V$/E4$+$V$H(B.....
$B$=$&$$$($P!"@N$NE/3Xl$KO"$l$F$+$l!"=q:X$NCf$G$J$/!"$=$3$G$8$C$/$j4pK\E*$J$3$H$r9M$($?$j$7$?$b$N$@!#(B

$B%U!<%`!"5HED$5$s$NK\$N=*$o$j$NJ}$K=P$F$/$k!"%j%R%M%m%&%#%A$H$+%\%[%J!<$H$+!"LpLn7rB@O:$5$s$N$*M'C#$P$+$j!#D9$$$3$HJY6/$7$F$J$+$C$?$3$H$N%D%1$G$9$J!A!#(B
Id: #a19981125093813$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Wed Nov 25 09:38:13 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981124154215
URL: samaki@hs.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Name: $B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $B2J3X
$B!!B<>eM[0lO:JT!X8=Be2J3XO@$NL>Cx!Y!JCf8x?7=q!K$rFI$_D>$7$^$7$?!#(B
$B!!%/!<%s$N$H$3$m$GB<>e$5$s$,!V2J3X

Id: #a19981124234026$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 23:40:26 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981124160351
Name: $B Subject: $B$(!<$C$H!&!&!&(B

$B!t3{(B $B9@LwMM!#(B
$B$^$:!"$*L>A0$N4A;z$,%/%i%i$K$OFq$7$/$FFI$a$^$;$s!#(B
$B$G!*?'!9$J$$G>$_$=$r$D$+$C$F!"@gBfL#A9$d?.=#L#A9$r2C$($F9M$($^$7$?!#(B
$B!V$+$b(B $B$R$m$d$9!WMM$G$9$M!)(B

$B$G!"%/%i%i:>5=;U$,@j$C$?$H$3$m!&!&!&(B
$B3{$5$s$O!"#3#1:P$N $B$7$+$b!"6bM;4X78$GL>$r9l$+$9!"%X%C%8%U%!%s%I!)(B
$B%G%j%P%F%#%VK|:P!)(B

$B!&!&!&$3$s$J$s$G$^$7$?$1$I!0!0(B;

$B;kLn$K$O$$$C$F$J$$!"$H$$$&$N$r%O%$%+%iIw$K$$$&$H(B
$B!V%"%&%H%*%V4cCf!W$C$F$3$H$G$7$g$&$+$M!#(B

$B!tH,LZMM!#(B
$B$O$8$a$^$7$F!#7G<(HD>e$G7Z!9$7$/8}$rJ9$/$3$H$r$*5v$7$/$@$5$$!#(B
$B;d$O$3$NE_$K%9%j%i%s%+$X$H%\%i%s%F%#%"$K$$$-$^$9!#(B
$B9q:]%\%i%s%F%#%"$K6=L#$r$b$C$?$N$O!"9b9;$N28;U$,%[%s%8%e%i%9$K9T$C$?$3$H$G$9!#(B
$BH`$O;d$?$A$K6(NOBb$d!"(BNPO$B$N$3$H$rOC$7$F$/$l$?$N$G$9!#(B
$B%[%s%8%e%i%9$O!";d$N1J1s$N>l=j$G$9!#(B
$B$$$D$+!"9T$C$F$_$?$$$G$9!#(B
$BH,LZMM$,!"%[%s%8%e%i%9$N$3$H$rOCBj$K$J$5$C$F$$$?$N$G!"(B
$B$A$g$C$H2{$+$7$/$J$C$?
$B!t$O$j!A$A$c$s(B
$B%/%i%i$,$_$s$J$NG/Np$r8m9M$7$F$?$3$H$G$=$s$J$K>P$C$F$b$i$($?$i$J$s$+!"%/%i%i$O$&$l$7$$$h!#(B
$B$=$s$J$KLLGr$$$N$G$7$g$&$+!)$&!<$`!&!&!&(B
$B$^$?!"$_$s$J$r>P$o$;$k$
Id: #a19981124215759$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 21:57:59 1998
Name: $B2q Subject: $B$*Ni$+$?$,$?(B
$B#1!%(B   $B$=$l$K$7$F$b!"$=$&!"$=$&!"AX$J$s$G$9$,!"(B
     $B0l>>$5$s$NB?JQ?t(I%%%$B$d!"?t3X$N%P%C%/(BNo$B$N;3:j$5$s$N(B
     Faisceau$B$NM}O@-5!&-6$d!"(I%%%$B:8$K0l>>$5$s$N=q$$$?(BCousin$BLdBj(B
     $B$"$k$H$$$($P!":8!"1&$K(I%%%$B$C$F6q9g$K1&1}:81}$7$F$^$7$?$,(B
     $B9uLZ$5$s$N!X(B $BAX$NOC(B $B!Y$G!"$d$C$HMn$ACe$$$F!"<+J,$NF,$G(B
     $B9M$(=P$;$=$&$G$9(B
     $B46/$7%*%^%1$rIU$1$F!"%M%C%H;2>H=PMh$:!"IT9,$K$b(B
     $B1&1}:81}$7$F$kJ}$r5_$&;v$O2DG=$G$9(B    
$B#2!%(B $B$J$s$+!"9uLZ$5$s$dCfEg$5$s$+$i$O!":4F#$5$s$H?y1:$5$s$N?tM}2J3X$G$N(B
     $B!X(B $BBPCL!&?t3X$NJ}8~(B $B!Y$d(B $BElBg?tM}8&$G:G8e$N#1:}$rGc$C$F$7$^$C$?(B
     $B?t3X$N$"$f$_(B15-1$B$N(B $B!X(B $B:4F#44IW;f$h$j0l8@8f0';"$,$"$j$^$9(B $B!Y$K(B
     $B=P2q$C$?;~$N46F0$K6a$$$b$N$r46$8$F$7$^$7$^$9(B
     $B?t3X$G$bJ*M}$G$b$=$&$G$9$,!"MW$O!"$H$l$@$146F0E*$J35G04V$N(B
     $B=P2q$$$r

Id: #a19981124170121$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 17:01:21 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981124131327
Name: $BH,LZ!!LT(B
Subject: Hurricane's name is Mitch

$B;~ED$5$s!"CfJF;Y1g$K$U$l$F$$$?$@$$$F$"$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$9!#$?$@!";d$,4X$o$C$F$$$k$N$O(B$B%[%s%G%e%i%9:R32I|6=;Y1g(B$B$G%K%+%i%0%"$O$^$?$A$g$C$H0c$&AH?%$J$N$G$9!#@($/O"BS$7$F$^$9$,!"JLCDBN!#!J$9$4$$$J$"!"O"BS$@$C$F!K$^$"!"4V0c$($F$b!"$3$N%X%s!"%h%3$N$D$J$,$j$,7k9=$"$k!J$_$?$$!K$N$G

$B$3$N7G<(HD$K$h$j4X$o$j$,?<$$$N$O(B$B%K%+%i%0%!:R32I|6=;Y1g(B$B$G$9$M!#$=$l$O$o$+$C$F$$$?$N$G$9$,$R$H$3$H!J$H$$$&$K$O$H$F$bD9J8$@$C$?$,!K$I$&$7$F$b=q$-$?$+$C$?


Id: #a19981124165301$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 16:53:01 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981124160351
Name: $B$O$j$,$d(B
Subject: Re: $B%/%i%i$5$sEP>l(B

$B$O$j$,$d$G$9!%%/%i%i$5$s$H$*OC$7$F$_$F!$(B $B%[!<%`%Z!<%8(B$B$K:\$;$F$"$k!$(B $B!J#1G/$K#12sDy$a$k5!2q$,$"$k$+L5$$$+$H$$$&!$%M%/%?%$$rDy$a$?!K(B $B $B$G$b$5!$$"$?$7$a$C$F $B%/%i%i$5$s$N#7#0:P$/$i$$$H$$$&0u>]$K$O!$(B $B!V$*$m$m!%!%!%!W$H;W$&$h$j$+$O!$(B $B%O%J%7$rJ9$$$?$H$?$s$KGz>P$7$F$7$^$$$^$7$?!%(B $B!J$3$s$J$3$H8@$C$F$9$_$^$;$s$M!#(B $B$/$i$i$5$s!#(B $B$G$b!$(B $B$[$s$H$*$b$m$+$C$?$s$G$9$h!#!#!#!K(B
Id: #a19981124160351$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 16:03:51 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123202700
Name: $B3{(B $B9@Lw(B
Subject: Re: $B%/%i%i$5$sEP>l(B

$B;d$O$I$&;W$o$l$F$$$k$+!"IT0B$K$J$C$F$-$^$7$?!#$;$a$F!"!V;kLn$KF~$C$F$$$^$;$s!W$@$H$$$$$1$I!#(B
Id: #a19981124154215$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 15:42:15 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123064347
Name: $B3{(B $B9@Lw(B
Subject: Re: $B@UG$O@(B

$B%Z%s%m!<%:$NFI $B$=$NFI!#(B

$B$H$$$&$o$1$G!"5DO@$,$A$g$C$H;($9$.$^$;$s$+!#(B


Id: #a19981124131327$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 13:13:27 1998
Name: $B2q
Subject: $B2q
$B$o!<$$!"2q!#(B
$B$?$@J9$-$O$h$/$J$$$+$i!"2K$J$H$-H,LZ$5$s$N%K%+%i%0%";Y1g$K%+%s%Q$7$F!"CfEg$5$s$b%=!<%+%k$K$7$A$c$(!#(B
$B $B0J2<$OD.$NL14V?t3X?^=q<<$NB"=q<+K}$_$?$$$J$b$N$G$9$,!"$h$s$G$k2q $B $B$=$l$H!"(BGeometry and Quantum Field Theory$B!J%&!<%l%s%Y%C%/JT=8$N(BAMS$B$N$NCf$N!K(BFrank Quinn$B$N2F3X9;$G$N%l%/%A%c! $B$3$l$i?t3X$H$7$F<+N)$7$?2ACM$b;}$D$b$N$H!"$D$sFI$7$F$k(BPolchinski$B$J$s$+$N%.%c%C%W$r!"$I$A$i$b8@MU$H$7$F$O!X7PO)@QJ,!Y$,=P$F$/$k$N$G!"%(%i%$BgJQ$HITMQ0U$K$$$C$?$N$G$9$,!"!X:G6a?JJb$,$"$C$?!Y$N(Beprint$B$,$o$+$l$P!"$3$l$b$D$sFI$7$F$_$?$$$h$&$J!)(B
$B7PO)@QJ,$+$i$O$8$^$C$F!";X?tDjM}$G=*$o$C$F$k$d$5$7$$$N$K!"Cf8644IW$5$s$NElBg$G$N%l%/%A%c!<%N!<%H!J>\$7$$$N$O6a$/%"%G%#%=%s$+$i!"$U$k$1$l$P%"%@%`%R%k%,!<$N$G$+$$$N!K(B
$B8EED$5$s$N$b!"El9)Bg$+$I$3$+$G$N=8Cf9V5A$N%N!<%H$,$G$^$o$C$F$k$H$$$&%&%o%5$@$1$I!#5nG/$N2r@O8&$N=U$N%5%$%P!<%/%&%#%C%F%s$+2?$+$N5-O?$O$"$k$N$G$O!#(B

$B$G!"%o%$%k$N%A%e!<%VO@J8$G$9$,!"%,%&%9%\%M$N%A%c!<%s$K$h$kFb:_E*>ZL@$rB%$7!"FC@-N`$N8&5f$,$O$8$^$C$?$3$H$,!"?t3X;K>e$N2ACM$G$O!#(B
$B%9%T%t%!%C%/$NHyJ,4v2?$NA4(B5$B:}$N5pBgK\$N(B5$B4,$N(Bpp385-388$B$K(BThe Generalized Gauss-Bonnet Theorem and What It Means for Mankind$B$J$s$F$N$,$"$k!#(B
$BJ#AG?t$NHy@Q$G$G$F$/$kJP3Q$N86M}$d!"%,%&%9%\%M$NAGKQ$J7A$G!"6I=jE*$JNL$rA4BN$K$o$?$C$F$7$3$7$3@QJ,$7$F$/$H!"Bg0hE*$J>pJs$,@0?t$G%Q%C$F=P$F$/$k$N$,!"2q $BId9fDjM}$O$h$/CN$i$J$$$1$I!"%R%k%D%'%V%k%U$K$3$l$rH/8+$7$?7P2a$r>\$7$/=q$$$?$N$,$"$k$s$G$9$h$M!#?72J3XE/3X$,H/8+$N$5$$$N%I%m%I%m$r8&5f$9$k$J$i!"$3$NJU$b$d$l$P$$$$$N$K!#(B
$B$5$F!"$3$N4V2?EY$+(Bup$B$7$?5HEDJ~9%$5$s$N?74)!X%G%#%i%C%/:nMQAG$N;X?tDjM}!Y$G$9$,!"%,%&%9%\%M!"Id9fDjM}!"%j!<%^%s%m%C%[$r;X?tDjM}$GAm3g$9$k$>$H!"(B27$B%Z!<%8$G@k8@$7$F$^$9!#(B
$B$^$?(B23$B%Z!<%8$G!"$[$H$s$IJP3Q$N86M}$NZL@$H(B68$BG/$N;X?tDjM}$N:G=i$N>ZL@$N9|AH$rHf3S$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B$(!<$H$=$l$+$i!"!XHs@~7A$NJPHyJ,$OHs2D49$NJ}$K!Y$O%3%s%L$J$s$+$NHyJ,4v2?$r$5$7$F$k$h$&$K$h$^$l$A$c$$$^$9$M!"$=$&$$$&0U?^$8$c$J$+$C$?$s$@$1$I!"0U?^$=$N$b$N$,%b%d%b%d$7$F$k$+$iE12s$7$A$c$&$N$,$$$$$G$9$M!#$"$"%3%s%L$N$bJ)8l$G$9$,$A$c$s$HB7$($F$$$^$9!#2q
Id:
#a19981124125904$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 12:59:04 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981120232310
Name: $B3{(B $B9@Lw(B
Subject: Re: $B?tM}O@M}3X$N652J=q(B

$B!X?t3X4pACO@9V5A!Y$O!"?tM}O@M}3X$NF~LgCJ3,$O$H$C$/$N@N$K=*$($??M$,FI$`652J=q$G$9$N$G!"G0$N$?$a!#(B
Id: #a19981124120118$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 12:01:18 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123225526
URL: yutak@fa2.so-net.ne.jp
Name: $BGpLn(B $BM:B@(B
Subject: Alfred Gray
$B$O$8$a$^$7$F!"GpLn!J$+$7$N!K$H?=$7$^$9!#(B

Alfred Gray$B$,K4$/$J$C$?$N$G$9$+!#H`$N(BMathematica$B$r;H$C$?(B
"Modern Diferential Geometory of Curves and Surfaces"$B$O(B
$B?t3X$,@lLg$G$J$$;d$K$H$C$F!"$H$F$b3Z$7$$K\$G$7$?!#(B
$B4qNo$J3($,K~:\$G$9$7!"2?$h$j$bO.$C$FM7$Y$k$3$H$,$G$-(B
$B$k$N$,NI$+$C$?$G$9!#(B

$B!t3N$+BhFsHG$b$G$F$$$k$O$:$G$9$M!#(B

Id: #a19981124052039$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 05:20:39 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123202700
Name: $B$I$b!"$\$1$@$*$7B"%/%i%i$G$9!0!0!((B
Subject: $BAa5/$-$O#51_$NF@(B

$B$I!"$I$b$C!0!0(B;
$B%a%S%&%9$NMq$K25=w%/%i%i$,#1?M$G>h$j9~$s$G$-$^$7$?!0!0(B;
$B%H%%%Q%/%"%^%k$b$S$C$/$j$7$?$@$m$&$J!&!&!&!#(B

$B@gBf$O!"$$$^Bg$-$JCO?L$,$"$j$^$7$?$M! $B$J$s$+!"%/%i%i$$$D$bCO?L%M%?$,B?$$$>!0!0(B;
$B$3$3$N7G<(HD$K$-$F$k%*%8%$%A%c%sJ}!"$*$O$h$&$4$6$$$^!<$9!#(B
$B%/%i%i$b!"%W%k%3%.?)$Y$F$9$0?2$A$c$C$?$N$G$b$&$*L\3P$a$J$N!
$B$$$d!.GH$5$s$K$*L\$K$+$+$l$F$H$F$b4r$7$+$C$?$G$9!#(B

$BE8Mw2q$b7k9=@967$G$7$?!#$h$+$C$?$h$+$C$?!#(B
$B$?$@!"!I%+%(%k$NLD$-@
$B$b$7$+$7$F!"$o$?$J$Y$5$s$H%/%i%i$N#2%7%g%C%H$r8+$?$$?M$C$F$*$i$l$^$9$+$M$'!)(B
$B$J$i$P!"?eMKF|$K$G$b2J3X4[$K9T$C$F%G%8%+%a$G%Q%7%c$7$F$-$^$9$+!)(B

$B9uLZ$5$s$,FH?H$@$J$s$F%S%C%/%j%I%s%-! $B$&!<$`!"!"!"(B
$B$^$@$^$@%/%i%i$KM}7O@$3&$O0E9u$NCO$@$o!&!&!&(B

$B$=$l$G$O!"$_$J$5$s!":#F|$b#1F|AGE($JF|$r!*(B

$B%/%i%i$G$7$?(B

$B#P#S(B
$B8<$A$c$s$X(B
$B%/%i%i$+$iD>I.NxJ8$r$7$?$?$a$F$*$$$?$N$G!"%Q%7%j$o$?$J$Y$5$s$+$i$b$i$C$F$/$@$5$$$M$C(B

$B$A$e$C(B
Id: #a19981124041039$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 04:10:39 1998
In-Reply-To: #a19981124025123
Name: $B2q Subject: $B$($($C!"%(%S%i$N@h@8$@!
$B$I$C!"$I!<$b%a%A%c%/%A%c$JOC$K$*IU$-9g$$D:$-$^$7$F!A(B
$B$3$N%\!<%I$C$F!"$9$4$$$N$G$9$M(B
$B:#!"GR8+CW$7$^$7$?FbMF$O!";d$K$H$C$F!"$b$N$9$4!<$$$b$N$G$9(B
$B$^$5$+!"$3$3$^$G(I%%%$B?@?q$r8x3+D:$1$k$J$s$F(B

$B@h@8$N=j!"GR8+$5$;$FD:$$$F$^$9(B
$BFC$K!"(Bgakkai.ps$B!IJl6u4V(B $B$H(B String Duality$B!I$N=q$-=P$7$O!"(B
$B%+%C%3$$$$$G$9$%!A(B
$B@h@8!*(B $B$3$l$+$i$b!"2f!9%U%!%s$N$?$a$K$b!"LLGr$$O@J8(B
$B%8%c%s%8%c%s=q$$$F$/$@$5$$(B
$B:G6a$a$C$-$jE_$i$7$/$J$j$^$7$?$N$G!"$*BNBg@Z$K!*(B

Id: #a19981124025123$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 02:51:23 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981122215142
URL: http://www.kusm.kyoto-u.ac.jp/~nakajima/nakajima-j.html
Name: $BCfEg(B $B7<(B
Subject: $B!V2q
>(1) $B2OLn$5$s$NAm@b$O!"7PO)@QJ,$NCM$r(B $BB?MMBN$Ne$NA4$F$N@\B3$N$J$9L58Be$G(B,
Chern-Simons $BHF4X?t$r7PO)@QJ,$7$F(B, 3$BZL@$5$l(B
$B$F$$$^$;$s$N$G(B, $B?t3XE*$JDj5A$H$O8@$($^$;$s(B.

1. $B7PO)@QJ,$,B8:_$9$k$H?.$8$k$3$H$K$7$F(B, $B4v$D$+$N$=$NK~$?$9$Y$-@-e$NDj5A$,ZL@$7$^$9(B.

>    $B$^$?!"$=$N7W;;$K$O!"8~$-IU$1IT2DG=$JJD6JLL$bESCf$NCJ3,$G(B
>    $B4X78$7$F$/$kMM$J;v$O$"$k$N$G$7$g$&$+(B

$B8~$-$E$1!v2DG=!v$JJD6JLL$N>e$N6&7A>lM}O@(B($B9uLZ@h@8$N$4@lLg$G$9(B)$B$H?<$/4X(B
$B78$7$F$$$^$9(B. $B8~$-$E$1IT2DG=$JJD6JLL$O(B, $B=P$F$-$^$;$s(B.

>(2) $BBe?t4v2?3X$C$F!"B?MMBN$rBe?tJ}Dx<0$G!"9M$($k;v$G$7$g(B
>    $BB?MMBN$NA4BN$N9=B$$r5,Dj$7$?=j$+$i;O$a$k$o$1$G$9$h$M(B
>    $BHyJ,4v2?3X$G$O!"B?MMBN$rJPHyJ,J}Dx<0$G!"9M$($k;v$G$9$h$M(B
>    $BB?MMBN$N6I=jE*9=B$$H$=$N$D$J$,$j$r5,Dj$7$?=j$+$i;O$a$k$N$G$9$h$M(B
>    Atiyah$B$N;X?tDjM}$O!"%j!<%^%s!&%m%C%[$NDjM}$N3HD%$@$C$F8@$o$l$^$9$,(B
>    $B=P$FMh$k%-!<%o!<%I$O!"$_$s$JHyJ,4v2?$N$b$N$N$h$&$K;W$($k$N$G$9$,(B
>    $B$^$?!"Be?t4v2?3X$N>l9g!"%3%s%Q%/%HJ#AGB?MMBN$G9M$($k$N$G$9$+$i!"(B
>    $B0l8}$KB?MMBN$H8@$C$F$b!"(B
>    $B$=$N0c$$$rE}0l$9$k;kE@$,8+$($^$;$s(B  Topogical$B$J;kE@$C$F;v$G$7$g$&$+(B

Atiyah-Singer$B$N;X?tDjM}$,(B, $B%j!<%^%s!&%m%C%[$NDjM}$N3HD%$G$"$k$3$H$rM}(B
$B2r$9$k$?$a$K$O(B, $B4v$D$+$N$3$H$rM}2r$7$J$/$F$O9T$1$^$;$s(B. ($B>ZL@$K$D$$$F(B
$BM}2r$9$k0JA0$K(B, $B$H$$$&0UL#$G$9(B.) $B$=$NItJ,$@$1$r=q$$$F$"$k652J=q$O(B, $BB8(B
$B:_$7$J$$$N$G(B, $B>ZL@$N=q$$$F$"$k652J=q(B($BNc$($P(B, $B:#EY$N4dGH$N%7%j!<%:$G$O(B
$B8EED@h@8$,<9I.$5$l$^$9(B)$B$rFI$^$l$k$7$+$J$$$+$H;W$$$^$9$,(B...

1. Atiyah-Singer$B$N;X?tDjM}$O(B, $B%3%s%Q%/%H$JHyJ,2DG=B?MMBN>e$NBJ1_7?JPHy(B
$BJ,:nMQAG$N;X?t$r%H%]%m%8%+%k$J>pJs$G=q$-I=$9<0$G$"$k(B.

2. $B%j!<%^%s!&%m%C%[$NDjM}$O(B, $BpJs$G=q$-I=$9(B
$B<0$G$"$k(B.

3. Hodge-deRham-Kodaira$B$ND4OB@QJ,O@$K$h$j(B, 2$B$N%3%[%b%m%8!<72$Ne$NBJ1_7?JPHyJ,:nMQAG(B(Dolbeault$B$N:nMQAG(B)$B$N;X?t$K(B
$BEy$7$$(B.

4. $B$J$i$J$$(B.

$BB?MMBN$H$$$&$N$O(B, $B%f!<%/%j%C%I6u4V$N3+=89g$rE=$j$"$o$;$F$G$-$k$b$N$G(B, 
$BDj$r(B
$BK~$?$7$^$9(B) $BJ#AG@5B'e$NJPHyJ,J}(B
$BDx<0$r07$$$^$9$,(B, $BJPHyJ,J}Dx<0$r;H$C$FE=$j$"$o$;$F$$$k$o$1$G$O$"$j$^$;(B
$B$s(B.

$B$=$l$+$i(B$B%V%?%M%3$5$s(B:

> $B$G$b(BTopological Quantum Field Theory $B$+$i(B4$Be$N#3'$7$?OHAH$_$G(B, $B>e$NITJQNL$O$=$NNc$G$9$,(B, $B$=(B
$B$l$K8B$k$o$1$G$O$"$j$^$;$s(B. $B$@$+$i(B, $B!V(BTopological .. $B$+$i!W$H$$$&8@$$(B
$BJ}$OITE,Ev$G$9(B.

$B8@MU$O$H$b$"$l(B, $B#3$NM}O@$G$O$=$lDx6/$$@)Ls$,$J$$(B
$B$N$G(B, $B$d$jJ}$,I,MW$G$9(B. $B:G6a(B, $BBg?JJb$,$"$j$^$7$?$,(B....

> $BHs@~7A$NJPHyJ,$OHs2D49$NJ}$K0z$CD%$i$l$F9T$-$=$&$G(B...

$B2?$G$3$N$h$&$K;W$o$l$?$N$+J,$+$j$^$;$s$,(B, $BHs@~7A$NJPHyJ,J}Dx<0$HHs2D49(B
$BHyJ,4v2?$O(B, $B$=$lDx4X78$O$"$j$^$;$s(B. ($BAPBP@-$^$G9T$/$H$=$&$G$b$J$$$,(B)

Id: #a19981124015028$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 01:50:28 1998
URL: kensho@buddhist.forum.or.jp
Name: $B82@55o;N(B
Subject: $B%j%t%!%$%P%k$,B?$$$G$9(B
$B!d9uLZ$5$s$O#5#0Be$G!"$O$j$,$d$5$s$O#7#0Be$@$m$&$H;W$C$F$$$?!#(B
$B$"$i$f$kJ,Ln$G%j%t%!%$%P%k$,B?$$$N$G!"e$NJ}$,%$%s%?!<%M%C%H$K$$$D$b9T$-Ev$?$k$[$I$K(B
$B$*$i$l$?$i!":#G/$b#3!A#4!s$N7P:Q@.D9$7$F$$$k$G$7$g$&!#(B

Id: #a19981124000159$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Thu Nov 24 00:01:59 1998
Name: ria
Subject: $BD4::6(NO
$BD0$-
$BB46HO@J8$GD0$- $BD4::$NBP>] $BBg3X$K?J3X$7$?;~$NOC$rJ9$-$?$$$H9M$($F$$$^$9!#(B
$BD0$-A0(B
$B$b=P$7$^$;$s!#!K(B $B$<$R!"$46(NO$*4j$$$7$^$9!#(B
$B!&D0$- $B!&>l=j$O0l?)$^$?$OJ8?)$rM=Dj$7$F$$$^$9!#!J4uK>$,$"$l$PJQ99$7$^$9!#!K(B
$B!&;~4V$O(B1$B;~4VDxEY$+$+$j$^$9!#(B
$B!JF|Dx$O=PMh$k$@$13'$5$s$K9g$o$;$^$9$N$G4uK>$NF|;~$r65$($F2<$5$$!#!K(B

$B650i3XIt(B4$BG/(B $B9)F#(B $BL@H~(B
ria@mbd.sphere.ne.jp
022-272-9857$B!J8F!K(B


Id: #a19981123225526$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 22:55:26 1998
Name: $B%V%?%M%3(B
Subject: $B$O$j$,$d$5$s!"D9@8$-$7$F2<$5$$(B

$B:rF|$N2q $B$=$l$G!" http://bianchi.umd.edu/
$B$H$$$&H~$7$$%Z!<%8$N(B
http://bianchi.umd.edu/Memorial/index.html
$B$K$h$l$P!":#G/$N(B10$B7nKv$K!"%9%Z%$%s$K5R;`!#(B
$B%O%j!<$5$s5$$r$D$1$F!#%/%i%i$O@;=w!J@;%U%i%s%7%9%3$N:G=i$N=wDo;R!K$@$+$i!"Ar<0Bg9%$-L<$+$b$M!)!)(B
$B$G!"8N(BGray$B$NK\$K$O%A%c!<%s$d%0%l%$$N%"%$%G%"$K$h$C$F!"%o%$%k$NDjM}$,$&$^$/2r@b$5$l$F$?$H;W$&!#MhG/=U%a%j!<%i%s%IBg$G5-G0%+%s%U%!%l%s%9$H$+!#(B
$B $B$G$b!"(B TopologicalQuantumField $B$+$i(B4$B $B$5$F $B!XHyJ,4v2?3X$G$O!"B?MMBN$rJPHyJ,J}Dx<0$G!"9M$($k;v$G$9$h$M!Y$J$s$F8@$o$l$k$H%S%S%C$A$c$&!#$^$"6JN($J$s$+$r9M$($k8EE5E*$G$N$I$+$J%T%/%K%C%/%i%s%I$,%V%?%M%3$NHyJ,4v2?$G!"Hs@~7A$NJPHyJ,$OHs2D49$NJ}$K$R$C$Q$i$l$F$$$+$l$=$&$G(B...
$B$G!"$$$m$$$m$J4v2?$,$"$C$F!"$@$s$@$s$HJ*M}$N@$3&$,$=$l$i$rAmF00w$7$F8+$($F$/$l$P!"@-5^$K2?$,E}0l;kE@$+0l$D$+Fs$D$N$b$N$r$"$2$k$3$H$O$J$$$H;W$&$N$G$9$,!";H$o$l$kF;6qN)$F!J%b%8%e%i%$$@$C$?$j%0%i%9%^%s?t$@$C$?$j!K$,$$$h$$$h3H$,$C$F$-$F$F!"$3$N@h$[$s$H$I$&$J$k$s$G$7$g$&$M!)!)(B
Id: #a19981123214220$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 21:42:20 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123202700
Name: $B$O$j$,$d(B
Subject: $B#7#0:P$N$8$8$$$+$N$)!)!)!)(B

$B$"$N!$$J$s$G$"$?$7$a$,#7#0:PBe$K$J$C$?$s$@$+!%!%!%(B

$B$^!$$$$$$d!$%/%i%i$5$s$h$j:P>e$J$N$OF1$8$3$H!%!%!%!V$O$j$,$d$N7G<(HD!W(B
http://www.etl.go.jp/~harigaya/BBS/spool/log.html
$B$K!$%U%)%m!<$7$F$*$-$^$7$?!%(B

$B%/%i%i$5$s!$$D$/$P;T$N!$!V9a?IHS20!W$K8=$l$k$N$O$$$D$G$7$g$+!)(B


Id: #a19981123202700$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 20:27:00 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123160126
Name: $B;b;RJ3?W?@=P54KW<7E>H,E]>.GH(B
Subject: $B%/%i%i$5$sEP>l(B

$B!!$($C$H!"#2#1!$#2#2$H9q5;4[$G%m%\%C%H%3%s%F%9%H$KIU$-9g$C$F$$$F!"(B50$B;~4V$V$j$/$i$$$K(B $B$3$3$rGA$$$?$i!"$J$s$HBgJQ$J>uBV!*Ev $B!!$G!":#F|$O@gBf$G(B$B%a%S%&%9$NMqE8(B$B$K=P$+$1$FH>F|$*5R$5$s$N$*Aj$B$&$il!*(B
$B9uLZ$5$s$N$4B:4i$r0lL\8+$F$_$?$+$C$?$=$&$G!#9uLZ$5$s$,
$B%/%i%i$5$s[)$/!'(B
      $B9uLZ$5$s$O#5#0Be$G!"$O$j$,$d$5$s$O#7#0Be$@$m$&$H;W$C$F$$$?(B
$B$F$J$o$1$G!"$3$s$I%/%i%i$5$s$r8r$($F%*%U2q$r$d$k$3$H$K$$$?$7$^$7$?$N$G!"@gBf:_=;0J30$N=t;a$O(B $B$/$l$0$l$b9uLZ$5$s$KA"K>$N$"$^$j$N$$$o$l$J$$?M3J967b$r$J$5$i$J$$$h$&!#$"!"$3$l$O:G6a$NO@5D$K$D$$$F(B $B8#@)$9$k0U?^$O$^$C$?$/$"$j$^$;$s$N$G!"O@@o$O$I$&$>$*B3$1$/$@$5$$!#(B
Id: #a19981123200458$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 20:04:58 1998
In-Reply-To: #a19981123150431
URL: masu@pp.iij4u.or.jp
Name: $B2q Subject: $B#52sL\(B
$B$"$s$^$7!"8D?M$rBP>]$KHcH=$O$7$?$/L5$$$N$G$9$,(B

#$B8"0R$K<|$o$l$:$KBgC@$J2>@b$rDs5/$7!"(I%%%(B#
$BFC$K8"0R0lHL$rH]Dj$7$F$$$?;v$J$IL5$$$H;W$$$^$9(B
$B<+J,<+?H$NM}2r$N;EJ}$+$i8@$C$F(B
$B$=$&$;$6$k$rF@$J$+$C$?$@$1$G$OL5$$$G$7$g$&$+(B
$BFq$7$/8@$($P!"B8:_<+BN$,Hs8"0RE*$G$"$k$H$+(I%%%$B$J$k$N$G$7$g$&$+(B
$B$@$+$i$H8@$C$F!"H`$i$K8"0R$,L5$$Lu$G$O$"$j$^$;$s(B
$BFC$K!"$*$A$c$a$J(B L.D.Landau$B;a$J$I$O!"8"0R$r$&$^$/;H$C$??M$G$O(B
$BL5$$$G$7$g$&$+(B
$B$G$9$+$i!"8@MU$8$j$OL7=b$7$^$9$,!"8"0R$r$b$C$?Hs8"0RE*?MJ*$@$C$F(B
$B$$$k$H$$$&;v$,!"J,#O#K$G$9$,!"(B
$BI,MW$H$$$&JU$j$,!"0z$C$+$+$j$^$9$M!<(B
$BJL$K$,$^$s$7$F!"L5M}$K$=$&$7$F$kLu$8$c!

Id: #a19981123160126$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 16:01:26 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981122103613
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: $B$"$"!":#F|!"9T$1$^$;$s$G$7$?(B

$B@gBf$N%a%S%&%9E8!":#F|9T$/M=Dj$@$C$?$N$G$9$,!"9T$1$^$;$s$G$7$?!#?=$7Lu$J$$$G$9!#@gBf6a9Y$NJ}$OGA$$$F$_$k$HLLGr$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B ($B>e$N(B In-Reply-To: $B$N9T$r%/%j%C%/$9$k$H@kEA5-;v$K%8%c%s%W$G$-$k!#(B)


Id: #a19981123152950$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 15:29:50 1998
In-Reply-To: #a19981123150431
Name: $B2q Subject: $B$H$&$H$*sL\(B
$B$*$C$7$c$k;v$O!$$o$+$j$^$9(B
$B$G$b!";d$,8@$$$?$$$N$O!"%U%!%s$J$i%U%!%s$i$7$/$7$h$&$h(I%%%$B$C$F;v$J$s$G$9(B
$B<+J,$,!"$"$?$+$b!"(BA.Einstein $B$NG!$/$K(I%%%$B$G$9(B
$BOC$N

Id: #a19981123150431$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 15:04:31 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981123130057
URL: http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~sn2y-tnk/danwa.htm
Name: $BGrF,2'(B
Subject: $BDLG0$rBGGK$9$k$3$H!'!V2q
$B!V2ql$3$=$,!"3XLd$K$*$$$F!"(B
$B8"0R$K<|$o$l$:$KBgC@$J2>@b$rDs5/$7!"$=$l$rl$G!"?7M}O@$r^$r^$7$?J*M}3X2q$NBgN)$A$K2?$i$+$NZ$5$l$?$3$H$K$"$j$^$9!#(B

$B2J3X$K$*$$$F$O!"8E$$M}O@$OC1$KGK4~$5$l$k$N$G$O$J$/!"?7$7$$M}O@$N(B
$B$J$+$KItJ,E*$J??M}$H$7$FJ]B8$5$l$k$N$,IaDL$G$9!#(B
$BAjBP@-M}O@$dNL;RNO3X$O!"0l8+$9$k$HH?>o<1E*$J5U@b$K(B
$BK~$A$F$$$k$h$&$K$b8+$($^$9$,!"$=$l$O$:$C$H>o<1E*$J8EE5J*M}3X(B
$B$r!"0lDj$N>r7o$N2<$GF3$-=P$7$&$kM}O@$J$N$G$9!#(B

$BAjBP@-M}O@$N4pAC86M}$H$$$($P!"!VEy2A86M}!W$d!V8wB.EYITJQ$N86M}!W(B
$B$NMM$J$b$N$O!"Z$r$^$L$+$l$k6u5u$J8x<0$G$O$J$/!"(B
$B>o$K87L)$J$k@b$G$"$k(B
$B$3$H$rN)>Z$G$-$k$b$N$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

Id: #a19981123130057$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 13:00:57 1998
In-Reply-To: #a19981123095415
Name: $B2q Subject: $B#32sL\$K$J$C$F$7$^$$$^$7$?(B
$B%$%$%+%2%s$J2#$d$j$G<:Ni$7$^$9(B
$BAjBPJ}$r;}$?$l$F$$$kJ}$,B?$$$N$G$O(B
$B$J$$$G$7$g$&$+(B    $BAjl$X1~1g$K$J$s$+9T$-$^$;$s$h(B
$B3Z$7$`;v$,=PMh$J$$?M$O!"%U%!%s$K$O8~$+$J$$$H;W$$$^$9(B
$B$H$$$C$F$b!";d$O!"%;%j%(#A$X9T$C$?CfED;a$/$i$$$K$7$+4X?4$"$j$^$;$s$1$I(B
$B$J$s$+!"G3$($kMM$J%(%-%5%$%F%#%s%0$J;v$C$FL5$$$b$N$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

Id: #a19981123095415$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 09:54:15 1998
URL: http://www.asahi-net.or.jp/~sn2y-tnk/danwa.htm
Name: $BGrF,2'(B
Subject: $BAjBP
$B!V2?$G$bN"7G<(HD!W$G!"$O$^$@$5$s$+$i!";d$N$3$3?tF|$N4V$NEj9F$O(B
$B2?$rL\E*$H$7$F9T$o$l$F$$$k$N$+!"$H$$$&$*?R$M$,$"$j$^$7$?!#(B
http://zakuro.math.tohoku.ac.jp/~kuroki/keijiban/x0000.html#x19981123004841
$B0lHL@-$N$"$kLdBj$J$N$G!"!VI=!W$N7G<(HD$G$*Ez$($7$^$9!#(B

$B;d$,9uLZ$5$s$N!V$J$s$G$b7G<(HD#2!W$K=P$7$?Ej9F$O!"!V?7$7$$2J3XE/3X!W$r>'F;(B
$B$9$k?M$?$A$N5DO@$K4p$E$$$F!VAjBPu67$,$"$k$h$&$K;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B%Q%i%@%$%`AjBPo$KIaJW2=2DG=$J$b$N$@$1$,2ACM$r;}$A$^$9$,!"(B
$B%Q%i%@%$%`AjBPe!":x3P$G(B
$B$"$jFHCG$K2a$.$J$$$N$G$9$,!"$=$l$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"$=$l$O2f!9$N@8$-$F$$$k;~Be(B
$B$NGyA3$H$7$?!V5$J,!W$r!"NI$/H?1G$7$F$$$^$9!#8=Be$O!"MM!9$N!V;(5oE*$J;WA[!W(B
$B$N9??e$NCf$K$"$C$F!">/$J$+$i$L?M$,!VAjBPM\$5$;$k$3(B
$B$H$r?4$,$1$F$$$^$9!#$H$/$K(B

$B#1!!o$K0[$J$k8+2r$r;}$D?M$H$N(B
$B!!!!BPOC$rDL$8$F!"$=$N5R4QE*BEEv@-$r6cL#$7$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#(B
$B#2!!$=$N:]!"e$GTn$7$$%G!<%?$,$"$k!K(B
$B>e$N$h$&$J!"HcH=E*$JM}@-$r^>M\$9$k>e$G!"AjBPe$,!";d$,!"$3$3?tF|4V$K!"!V$J$s$G$b7G<(HD#2!W$KEj9F$7$?L\E*$G$9!#(B
$B;d$N5DO@$,!"$3$NL\E*$rC#$7$?$b$N$G$"$k$+$I$&$+$O!"JL$H$7$F$b!"(B
$B2?$N$?$a$K!"$3$N7G<(HD$KEj9F$7$?$+$r$4M}2rBW$1$l$P9,?S$G$9!#(B

Id: #a19981123094114$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 09:41:14 1998
In-Reply-To: #a19981123064347
Name: $B2q Subject: $B#22sL\$G$9(B
R.Penrose$B;a$,!"IT40A4@-DjM}$K$D$$$F8m2r$7$F$$$?;v$,(B
$BOCBj$K$J$C$F$k$h$&$G$9$,!"(B
$BB?$/$NFI!9$5$l$kJ}$,!"?t3X4pACO@$r@5$7$/M}2r$7$FM_$7$$$H$$$&(B
$BK>$_$r$*;}$A$J$iJL$G$9$,!"$?$@I>O@$5$l$k$@$1$C$F$$$&$N$O(B
$B%`%@$J$h$&$K;W$$$^$9$,(B

Id: #a19981123064347$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 06:43:47 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981122111500
Name: $B0K@*EDE/<#(B
Subject: $B@UG$O@(B

$B9uLZ$5$s$HKRLn$5$s$N$d$j$H$j$O$+$_9g$&MM;R$,$J$$$N$G$"$i$?$a$F(B $BLdBj$rN)$FD>$7$?$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B
  1. $B%Z%s%m!<%:$,IT40A4@-DjM}$r8m2r$9$k$3$H$K$D$$$F?tM}O@M}3X$B%Z%s%m!<%:$NFI$B0lIt$N2J3X$B0lIt$NM}2J650iO@.<*$K64$s$G%Q%i%@%$%`O@$r8m2r$9$k$3$H$K$D$$$F2J3XO@J}$r4^$`!K$K$O@UG$$,$"$k$+!)(B
$B$o$?$7$N8+$k$H$3$m!J#1!K$H!J#3!K$,%Q%i%l%k$G!J#2!K$H!J#4!K$,%Q%i%l%k$G$9!#(B $B$G!"!J#1!K$H!J#3!K$X$NEz$($OL@$i$+$K%N!<$@$H;W$$$^$9!J9uLZ$5$s$O!J#3!K$K$D$$$F0[O@$,$"$k$H;W$$$^$9$,!K!#%Z%s%m!<%:$K$7$m2J3X7$/(B $BH/8@$r$7$?Ev?M$?$A$,$H$k$Y$-$b$N$G$9!#(B

$B$=$N>e$G!"@UG$$NM-L5$H2?$r$9$Y$-$+$OJLLdBj!#!JL\$NA0$K;R$I$b$,$*$\$l$F$$$k>l9g!"$=$N;R$,(B $B$*$\$l$?$3$H$K4X$7$F2?$N@UG$$b$J$/$F$b=u$1$k$Y$-$@$H$$$&$N$HF1$8(B----$BFC$K!"$*$\$l$5$;$?Ev?M$?$A$,=u$1$kMM;R$,$J$$>l9g$H$+!#!K:84,$5$s$,?4G[$7$F$*$i$l$k$h$&$J!"M}2J650i$N$$$/Kv$K$+$+$o$kLdBj$K$D$$$F2J3XE/3XfIW$J$s$@$m$&$+!K!#0J>e$,!":G6a$N$d$j$H$j$KBP$9$k0l2J3XE/3X $B$A$J$_$K!"2J3XSocial Studies of Science$B!J2J3X


Id: #a19981123020042$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Mon Nov 23 02:00:42 1998
Name: $B%/%i%i(B
Subject: $B%3%m%s%V%9$NMq(B

$B%/%i%i$b%a%S%&%9%(%C%0!"9T$/$h!A"v(B

$B8<$A$c$s!"2q$($k$H$$$$$M(B!

$B$?$@!*(B
$B%?%@!*(B
Id: #a19981122221516$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 22:15:16 1998
Name: $B%V%?%M%3(B
Subject: $B2q
$B;XL>$5$l$?$b$N$G$O$J$$$G$9$,!"0lIt$K1~$($5$;$FD:$-$^$9!#(B

Q:Atiyah$B$N;X?tDjM}$O!"%j!<%^%s!&%m%C%[$NDjM}$N3HD%$@$C$F8@$o$l$^$9$,(B $B=P$FMh$k%-!<%o!<%I$O!"$_$s$JHyJ,4v2?$N$b$N$N$h$&$K;W$($k$N$G$9$,(B

A:$B$J$s$G$b(B2$B$K>R2p$7$?!X%G%#%i%C%/:nMQAG$N;X?tDjM}!Y6&N)$O$J$+$J$+$h$5$=$&$JK\$G$9!#(B

Q:$B#1#9#3#8G/#87n#1#4F|?M$,(B $B;I7c$5$l$?$N$G$7$g$&$+(B

A:$B5-21$K<+?.$,$J$$$,!"%U%i%s%9HG%o%$%kA4=8$K$O4^$^$l$:!"%=O"HG%o%$%kA4=8$K:\$C$F$$$k$N$,!"JT=8$7$?%"!<%N%k%I$N@($$$H$3$G$O!)$"$j$c!"!X$"$f$_!Y$b(B"Tube"$B$bB_$7=P$7Cf$@(B....
Id: #a19981122215142$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 21:51:42 1998
Name: $B2q Subject: $B$O$8$a$^$7$F(B
$B$O$8$a$^$7$F!"(B
$B;d$O!"J*M}$H?t3X$N9%$-$J2q$K8@$o$;$FD:$-$^$9(B
$B$^$?!"7QB3$7$FEj9F$9$k;v$b!"=PMh$J$$$N$G!"0-$7$+$i$:(B
$B$H$3$m$G(B
$B2J3XE*$H$$$&8@MU$K$I$l$[$I$N0UL#$,$"$k$G$7$g$&$+(B
$B62$i$/B?$/$N4k6H$G$O!"2J3XE*$H$$$&8@MU$,8r$o$5$l$k;v$O>/$J$$$N$G$9(B
$B$=$3$G$O!"8@$&$H$7$F$b!I3Nf$5$s$N(BTopologicalQuantumField(I%%%(B
$B$K?(H/$5$l$?;v$K;O$^$k$N$G$9$,!"(B
(1) $B2OLn$5$s$NAm@b$O!"7PO)@QJ,$NCM$r(B $BB?MMBN$Nl9g!"%3%s%Q%/%HJ#AGB?MMBN$G9M$($k$N$G$9$+$i!"(B
    $B0l8}$KB?MMBN$H8@$C$F$b!"(B
    $B$=$N0c$$$rE}0l$9$k;kE@$,8+$($^$;$s(B  Topogical$B$J;kE@$C$F;v$G$7$g$&$+(B
(3) $B?t3X%;%_%J!<$NJL:}$N!X(B $B8=Be?t3X$N$"$f$_!Y$KD9Ln@5$5$s$,=q$+$l$?(B
    Hermann Weyl$B$N(B $B!X(B ON THE VOLUME OF TUBES $B!Y$N2r@b!"(B
    $B$4Mw$K$J$j$^$7$?!)(B
    $BJ*M}E*H/A[$G!"B?MMBN$+$i5wN%#r$NHO0OFb$NBN@Q$,!"#r$NB?9`<0$K$J$C$F(B
    $B$=$N78?t$,!"%H%]%m%8%+%k$JITJQNL$rM?$($k$C$F$$$&DjM}(B
    $B$3$l!"#1#9#3#8G/#87n#1#4F|?M$,(B
    $B;I7c$5$l$?$N$G$7$g$&$+(B





Id: #a19981122143846$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 14:38:46 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981122140431
Name: $BKRLn(B

$B!V2PCf$N7*$r$R$i$&!W$H$$$&$h$j$O!"$`$7$m2P$N$J$$$H$3$m$K2P$r$*$3$=$&$H(B $B$7$F$^$;$s!)!d$O$^$@$5$s(B

$B!V$A$g$C$H%D%C%3%`$HJ,$+$i$J$$$HF($2$k!W!V$IAG?M$N%U%j!W$K$D$$$F$O6qBNE*$JNc$r$"$2$F$$$?$@$1$l$P$H;W$$$^$9!#:#8e$N;29M$K$7$?$$$H;W$$$^$9$N$G!#(B

$B!VAj


Id: #a19981122140431$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 14:04:31 1998
Name: $B$O$^$@$H$i$R$3(B
Subject: $B2PCf$N7*$r$R$i$&(B
$B$H$&$H$&$3$NF|$,Mh$^$7$?$M!J>P!K(B
$B;d$N69p'$J?4$G$O!"2J3XO@$N$H$-$NKRLn$5$s$O%$%d$G$7$?!#!J#2F|A0$N7G<(HD#2$G$NK=8@$O!"H>J,KRLn$5$sH>J,GrH12'$5$s!K(B
$BAG?M$N%U%j$7$F!"Aj

Id: #a19981122111500$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 11:15:00 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981122044836
Name: $BKRLn(B

$B9uLZ$5$s!"(B

$B9uLZ$5$s$NN(D>$JBVEY$OBgJQAG@2$i$7$$$b$N$H;W$C$F$*$j$^$9!#(B

$B2J3XO@HcH=$K4X78$7$?5DO@$K$*$1$kKRLn$5$s$NBVEY$O!"HcH=$rMH$2B- $B!V9uLZ$5$s$,$9$k5DO@$K$D$$$F!W$O!";d$,$9$k$b$N$O$+$J$jMH$2B-$K$$$o$;$F$$$?$@$1$l$P!"9uLZ$5$s$N5DO@$,7j$@$i$1$G$"$k$?$a$G$9!#(B

$B8=:_$N2J3XO@$KA4$/2?$NLdBj$b$J$$$H$$$&$o$1$G$O$J$$$G$7$g$&$7!"$=$l$KBP$9$k2J3X $B9uLZ$5$s$N5DO@$,$I$N$h$&$K7j$@$i$1$G$"$k$+$H$$$&Nc$r!":G?7$NEj9F$+$i$"(B $B$2$F$*$/$H!"(B

$B!V%Z%s%m!<%:$,?tM}O@M}3X$*$h$S$=$N6a@\J,Ln$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$N$G!"?tM}O@M}3X$*$h$S6a@\J,Ln$N@lLg2H$,%/%l!<%`$rIU$1$?!W$O(B A$B!b(BB$B!a(BC $B$N7?$NLdBj$K4X78$7$F$*$j!"!V2J3XO@$N@lLg2H$,2J3XO@$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$H$-!"2J3XO@$N@lLg2H$O$I$N$h$&$JBVEY$rN@-1>!9$rO@$8$F$b0UL#$,$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$J$s$+E57?E*$G$9$M!#%Z%s%m!<%:$OC1$K8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$N$G$O$J$/!"8m2r$7$F$$$k$o$1$G$9!#$3$3$GF1MM$J9T0Y$r$7$?!"$D$^$j2J3XO@$r8m2r$7$F$$$k$N$O!"Nc$($P:84,$5$s$,HcH=$5$l$F$$$k$h$&$J0lIt$NM}2J650iO@ $B$5$i$KLdBjE@$r$"$2$l$P!"$3$3$G!"!V8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?!W$H$$$&$$$$J}$r$7$?;~E@$G!"9uLZ$5$s$O0EL[$N$&$A$K!V8m2r$9$k$[$&$G$O$J$/8m2r$5$l$k$[$&$,0-$$!W$H$$$&!J$=$l0JA0$K@5Ev2=$5$l$F$$$k$o$1$G$O$J$$!KA0Ds$rF3F~$7$F$$$F!"$=$N$"$H$N5DO@$O$9$Y$F$=$NA0Ds$K=>$C$FE83+$5$l$F$$$^$9!#$=$N$h$&$J5DO@$N$7$+$?$K$O0UL#$,$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B$b$A$m$s!">e$N$h$&$J7j$@$i$1$N5DO@$r9uLZ$5$s$O7j$,$"$k$H$O;W$o$J$$$7HcH=$5$l$k$$$o$l$O$J$$$+$iJ86g$r$$$&$J$H$$$&$3$H$G$7$?$i!"$3$l0J>e$$$&$3$H$O$"$j$^$;$s$,!"$^$"!"HcH=$N@/<#E*0U?^$r1>!9$9$k$h$&$G$O9uLZ$5$s$b(B Andrew Ross $B$J$_$G$9$M!#(B


Id: #a19981122103613$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 10:36:13 1998
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: $B%a%S%&%9$NMqE8!&@gBf(B1998

$B%a%S%&%9$NMqE8!&@gBf(B1998$B$,:rF|$+$i;O$^$C$F$$$^$9$M!#4|4V$O(B1998$BG/(B11$B7n(B21$BF|(B[$BEZ(B]$B!A(B11$B7n(B26$BF|(B[$BLZ(B](24$BF|(B[$B2P(B]$B$O5Y4[(B)$B!"8aA0(B9$B;~(B30$BJ,!A8a8e(B4$B;~(B45$BJ,(B($BF~4[$O8a8e(B4$B;~$^$G(B)$B$G!">l=j$O(B$B@gBf;T2J3X4[(B$BFs3,FCJLE8<(<<$G$9!#(B

$B@gBf;T2J3X4[(B($B@gBf;T@DMU6hBf86?9NS8x1`(B4$BHV(B1$B9f(B)$B$X$N%"%/%;%9(B$B$O!"CO2l9g!"@gBf;T1DCO2l9g!"ElKL<+F0k#I#C!W$r9_$j!"H,25=w!&@^N)@~7PM3Ls(B20$BJ,$G$9!#(B

$B$5$i$K>\$7$$>pJs$K$D$$$F$O(B$B%a%S%&%9$NMqE8$N%Z!<%8(B$B$r8+$F2<$5$$!#(B

$BKM$OL@F|8+$K9T$/$3$H$K$9$k$+$J!#(B


Id: #a19981122044836$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sun Nov 22 04:48:36 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981121232726
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: $BBP>N@-$K$D$$$F(B

$BKRLn$5$s[)$/!"(B

$B9uLZ$5$s$,$J$s$+=q$$$F$^$7$?$,!"Nc$($P%Z%s%m!<%:$,IT40A4@-DjM}$r8m2r$9$k$N$O%Z%s%m!<%:$,0-$/$F!"2J3XO@$,8m2r$5$l$k$N$O8m2r$5$l$k$[$&$,0-$$$H$$$&$N$O$A$g$C$HN@-$,0-$$$h$&$K;W$$$^$9$M!#(B

$B$H$3$m$G!"$3$N0lO"$N5DO@$K$*$$$F!"%Z%s%m!<%:$K$D$$$F!";d$,2?$+8@$$$^$7$?$C$1!)(B $B$=$l$K!V8m2r$5$l$kJ}$,0-$$!W$J$s$F$3$H$rC/$,8@$C$?$s$@!)(B $B2J3XO@HcH=$K4X78$7$?5DO@$K$*$1$kKRLn$5$s$NBVEY$O!"HcH=$rMH$2B-$K8@$o$;$F2<$5$$!#;d$,5$$K$7$F$$$k$N$O!"KRLn$5$s$,<+J,$NM'?MC#$N$?$a$KKI1RE*$J5DO@$rE83+$7$F$$$k$N$G$O$J$$$+!"$H$$$&$3$H$J$N$G$9!#$=$l$J$i$=$&$HN)>l$r$O$C$-$j$5$;$F$/$l$J$$$H:$$j$^$9!#(B ($BN)>l$r$O$C$-$j$5$;$?>e$G$NMH$2B-

$B$3$l$G$*=*$$$K$9$k$H$"$^$j$K$bITLS$J$N$G!"!VBP>N@-!W$K4X$7$F;d$N0U8+$r=R$Y$^$9!#$^$:!"

$BJ,Ln(B A $B$N@lLg2H$,J,Ln(B B $B$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$H$-$K!"J,Ln(B C $B$N@lLg2H$O$I$N$h$&$JBVEY$r

$B!V%Z%s%m!<%:$,?tM}O@M}3X$*$h$S$=$N6a@\J,Ln$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$N$G!"?tM}O@M}3X$*$h$S6a@\J,Ln$N@lLg2H$,%/%l!<%`$rIU$1$?!W$O(B A$B!b(BB$B!a(BC $B$N7?$NLdBj$K4X78$7$F$*$j!"!V2J3XO@$N@lLg2H$,2J3XO@$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$H$-!"2J3XO@$N@lLg2H$O$I$N$h$&$JBVEY$rN@-1>!9$rO@$8$F$b0UL#$,$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B$=$l$O$=$&$@$H$7$F$b!"0lHLO@$H$7$F!";d$,$I$N$h$&$K9M$($F$$$k$+$K$D$$$F=R$Y$F$*$-$^$9!#(B

A$B!b(BB$B!a(BC $B$N>l9g$O!"8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?J,Ln(B A $B$N@lLg2H$,J,Ln(B B$B!a(BC $B$N@lLg2H$G$J$$$3$H$r4U$_$F!"J,Ln(B B$B!a(BC $B$N@lLg2H$O42MF$JBVEY$r7$/H/8@$N1F6ANO$,Bg$-$$>l9g$G$9!#Nc$($P!"8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$??MJ*$,Bg$-$J8"0R$N;}$Al9g$O!"$=$N8m2r$r$?$@$9$?$a$K!"J,Ln(B B$B!a(BC $B$N@lLg2H$N2??M$+$,%/%l!<%`$rIU$1$k$3$H$OI,MW$@$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

A$B!a(BB$B!a(BC $B$N>l9g$O!"J,Ln(B A $B$N@lLg2H$K$h$kF1$8J,Ln(B A $B$K4X$9$kH/8@$O?.MQ$5$l$k2DG=@-$,9b$$$N$G!"HcH=$NI,MW@-$O9b$$$H9M$($i$l$^$9!#$=$7$F!"F1$8J,Ln$N@lLg2H$OHcH=$KI,MW$J@53N$JCN<1$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$@$+$i!"FC$K$=$N1F6A$,Bg$-$$$H9M$($i$l$k>l9g$O!"N(@h$7$FF1N=$rHcH=$9$k@UG$$,$"$k$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B;d$,30It$+$i8+$?46$8$G$O!"?tM}O@M}3X$*$h$S$=$N6a@\J,Ln$K$O87$7$$?MC#$,7k9=$$$F!"$=$NJ,Ln$N@lLg2H$,Nc$($P%2!<%G%k$NIT40A4@-DjM}$K$D$$$F8m2r$r>7$/H/8@$r$7$?$j$9$k$H87$7$/HsFq$5$l$k$K0c$$$"$j$^$;$s!#$=$7$F!"@lLg2HC#$,%2!<%G%k$N;E;v$NNIN@-$r5$$K$9$k$J$i!"%Z%s%m!<%:$H2J3XO@

$BJdB-(B1$B!'(B $B%Z%s%m!<%:$b?tM}O@M}3Xl$b$"$k$H;W$$$^$9!#$=$N>l9g$O!"%Z%s%m!<%:$rHcH=$9$k?tM}O@M}3XH*$N@lLg2H$OF1$82J3X

$BJdB-(B2$B!'(B $B650i9T@/$K8m2r$5$l$?2J3XO@$,1F6A$rM?$($F$7$^$&2DG=@-$,$"$k$H$-!"2J3XO@$N@lLg2H$O$I$N$h$&$JBVEY$r


Id: #a19981121233056$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 23:30:56 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981120102412
Name: $B8EF2L@9-(B
Subject: $B:,$N?<$$LdBj!)(B

Name:$B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $BM}2J650i$HAjBP

$B!!M}2J650iO@.@n$5$s$bG@3XGn;N$G$9!K!#3XIt$NCf$G$O!"2J3Xl$,2J3X$rAjBP2=$7$h$&$H$$$&0U<1$K7R$,$C$F$$$k$+$bCN$l$^$;$s!J$\$/$N $B;(;o!X;yF8?4M}!Y#9#8G/#27n9f$G!"El5~3X7]Bg$N@h@8$,(B $B$3$s$J46$8$N$3$H=q$$$F$^$9!#855-;v$b$<$R$40lFI$r!#(B

$B!X8"0R$KO(B

$B!V$"$kCK;RBg3X@8!#K\?M$O65;U;VK>!"(B $BCOJ}9qN)Bg$N650i3XIt$KBh0l;VK>$GF~(B
$B3X!#$7$+$7!"(B $BDL3X$NESCf$K$"$kB>$N9qN)Bg$NCf$rDL$k$H$-!"<+J,$N3XNO$NDc(B
$B$5$r<~$j$+$i;XE&$5$l$F(B $B$$$k$h$&$G8*?H$N69$$;W$$$,$9$k$H$$$&!#<+J,$O#a19981121232726$B!!(B
(reply,
thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 23:27:26 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981120102412
Name: $BKRLn(B

$B:84,$5$s!"(B

$B$A$g$C$H46$8$,$o$+$C$F$-$^$7$?!#>\$7$$@bL@$r$I$&$b$"$j$,$H$&$4$6$$$^$9!#(B

$B$3$3$N$H$3$m6&F18&5fO$,=q$1$J$/$F$@$$$VJV;v$,CY$l$^$7$?!#(B

$B!!@hF|!"CfM}652J=q$NJT=82q5D$N8e!"#M$5$s!wElBg!'CO5e2=3X$H$*OC$7$J$,$i5"$j$^$7$?!#2J3X $B$X$(!"C/$J$s$G$7$g$&!)(B
$B!!IpB<=EOB$5$s!w9-EgBg$O(B ... $B!V<+A32J3X$O?M4V$,AOB$$7$?(B $B$b$N$GJQ2=$9$k!#<+A32J3X$O2J3X $B$&!<$s!"$^$"!"A0H>$rG'$a$J$$?M$O$"$s$^$j$$$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$+$H;W$&$N$G$9$,!"8eH>$N!V2J3XO$rFI$s$G8+$k$Y$-$H$O;W$$$^$9$,!">/$J$/$H$b!V $B>e$N$h$&$JeM[0lO:$N$$$C$F$$$k$3$H$H$b$[$H$s$I2?$N4X78$b$J$$!"C1$J$k!V8m2r!W$G$O$J$$$+$H;W$$$^$9!#(B

$B9uLZ$5$s$,$J$s$+=q$$$F$^$7$?$,!"Nc$($P%Z%s%m!<%:$,IT40A4@-DjM}$r8m2r$9$k$N$O%Z%s%m!<%:$,0-$/$F!"2J3XO@$,8m2r$5$l$k$N$O8m2r$5$l$k$[$&$,0-$$$H$$$&$N$O$A$g$C$HN@-$,0-$$$h$&$K;W$$$^$9$M!#(B


Id: #a19981121232340$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 23:23:40 1998
In-Reply-To: a0029.html#a19981121110741
Name: $B8EF2L@9-(B
Subject: Re:$BM}2J650i$H!V%/!<%s
Name: $B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $BM}2J650i$H!V%/!<%s

$B$3$3$r$\$/$NM'?M$N650i3X$dM}2J650i$N8&5f

$B$=$&$G$9$+!#$G$O!";d$,(B$B0JA0=q$$$?$3$l(B$B$K$D$$$F$N%3%a%s%H$,$$$?$@$1$k$H$&$l$7$$$G$9!# $B2?$+!"LdBj$,5/$-$F$$$^$9$+!#$=$l$H$b!";d$NG'<1ITB-$J$N$G$7$g$&$+!#(B


Id: #a19981121110741$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 11:07:41 1998
URL: samaki@hs.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Name: $B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $BM}2J650i$H!V%/!<%s
$B!!:84,7rCK$G$9!#(B
$B!!$$$^!"2J3X;K#M#L$N:4AR$5$s!w2#9q$X$N%3%a%s%H$r=q$$$FEj9F$7$?$H$3$m$G(B
$B$9!#:4AR$5$s$NJ8>O$rF~$l$k$H$3$A$i$K7G:\$G$-$J$$$N$G!"$3$l$@$1FI$s$G$b(B
$B$o$+$k$h$&$K=q$$$?$D$b$j$G$9!#(B
$B!!$3$3$r$\$/$NM'?M$N650i3X$dM}2J650i$N8&5fP$_$N$"$N?M!W$,%3%a%s%H$7$F$$$^$9$,!"$\$/$OAj(B(^^;)$B!#(B

$B!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!]!](B
$B!!:84,7rCK!wEl5~Bg3X650i3XItImB09bEy3X9;$G$9!#!!(B
$B!!:4AR$5$s$,652J=qJT=8$K$+$+$o$k$+$b!"$H$$$&$N$OJ9$$$F$$$^$9!#:#$K2q5D$G(B
$B0l=o$K$J$k$+$bCN$l$^$;$s$M(B(^^)$B!#(B
$B!!$\$/$O!"M}2J650i%"%+%G%_%:%`$,8=>l$HN%$l$F$$$k$H=q$-$^$7$?!#$b$A$m$s!"(B
$B$=$l$O0lHLO@$G!"$=$N%"%+%G%_%:%`FbIt$K$$$k$\$/$NM'?M!&CN?M$?$A$O!"8=>l46(B
$B3P$rBg@Z$K$7$h$&$HEX$a$F$$$^$9!#$7$+$7!"3X2q$N>eAXIt$r7A@.$7$F$$$k?M$?$A(B
$B$NB?$/$O0lCNH>2r$J!VC1=c%/!<%sP$rGc$C$F$$$k65;U$b$$$^$9$,!#$\$/$O$=$&$$$&65;U$OAjJ652JD4::41;a$J$I$H0l=o$K$J$C$F!"(B
$B$o$,9q$NM}2J650i2]Dx$r:n$C$F$$$k$o$1$G$9!#(B
$B!!=iEyM}2J650i$G$O$*$+$7$J.M}$H$$$&CDBN$rCf?4$K9T$o$l$O$8$a$F$$(B
$B$^$9!#$=$l$r!"%"%+%G%_%:%`FbIt$K$$$k$\$/$NM'?M!&CN?M$?$A$O4mW|$7$F$$$^(B
$B$9!#(B
$B!!$=$&$J$C$F$$$k860x$r!"Ln2H$5$s$dB<>eM[0lO:$5$s$K5a$a$k$H$$$&$N$b!"K\Ev(B
$B$OHr$1$?$[$&$,$$$$$+$bCN$l$^$;$s!#Ln2H$5$s$N!V$*Ez$(!W$rFI$s$G$b!"!V!HE/(B
$B3X!I$C$F$b$N$O!"AGKQ2r$J!VC1=c%/!<%s$NJ,Ln$G$I$&;H(B
$B$o$l$F$$$k$+$KCm0U$,$"$C$F$b$h$+$m$&$H;W$$$^$9!#!K(B
$B!!2?$;!"H`$i$K$+$+$k$H!"!V?7$7$$2J3X4Q!W$O6KCu67E*G'CN$d3X9;CN$Ol$+$i8@$($P!"2J3XCN<1$N$b$D!VAj(B
$BBP@-!W$X$N8@5Z$,$J$52a$.$k$H$$$&$N$OF10U$;$6$k$rF@$^$;$s!#3N$+!"%/!<%s$,(B
$B!X9=B$!Y$G!"652J=q$K$D$$$F=q$$$F$$$^$7$?!#DL>o2J3X$NCN$NOHAH$_!&J}K!O@$J(B
$B$I$r652J=q$rDL$8$FEA$($F$$$k$H!#652J=q$H$$$&$N$O!"CN$rBN7OE*$K65$($kF;6q(B
$B$G$9$+$i7k2L$H$7$F!V@dBP@-!W$K79/$72J3XO@$d2J3Xl$N65;U!"(B
$B@8EL$N4i$r;W$$Ib$+$Y!"$I$&$7$?$i$o$+$j$d$9$/$J$k$+$r9M$($^$9!#$*1"$GCfM}(B
$B$b9b9;2=3X$b$\$/$,<9I.$K;22C$7$?652J=q$O9b$$:NBrN($r8X$C$F$$$^$9!#<9I.l463P$OHs>o$KBg@Z$G$9!#$=$N$?$a$K$b!"$\$/$OA49q$G65;UAjJ3X=,;XF3MWNN!J#C#O#S!KM}2J$r;(;o$J$I$G$1$A$g$s$1$A$g(B
$B$s$KHcH=$7$F$$$^$9$,!"$b$7$+$7$?$i$h$/$J$C$?$+$J!"$H;W$&ItJ,$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B!!!VL\E*0U<1$r$b$C$?4Q;!!&Zl!!K\$H$7$F$O>.NSF;IW(B
$B!X2J3XE/3X!Y;:6H?^=q!K$KJQ$($i$l$^$9$+$i/$J$$$H;W$$$^$9!#(B
$B!!:#$^$G$N4Q;!!&l$G(B
$B$J$/$F$b$*$+$7$$$G$7$g$&!JC1=c5"G<;D$O$+$N!VC55f(B
$B$N2aDx!W$N%W%m%;%9%9%-%k$K$"$j!"652J=qD4::41!J652JD4::41$H$OJL!K$NCf$K$O(B
$B$=$&$$$&!V2J3X$NJ}K!!WDL$j$K652J=q$rE83+$7$J$$$HMn$H$9?M$,$$$^$9!#!V8z2L(B
$BE*$J%/!<%s]$rC!$3$&$H$9$kM>(B
$B!!$j2a>j$KH?BPB&$K9T$C$A$c$&$3$H$G$9$M!J$\$/$b4m$J$$$G$9!K!#(B

$B"#:84,7rCK(B(SAMAKI TAKEO)$B!'El5~Bg3X650i3XItImB09bEy3X9;!'2=3X(B
$B"#")(B164-0014$BCfLn6hFnBf(B1-15-1$BEEOC(B03-3377-3411FAX03-3377-3415$B!!(B
$B"#(BE-MAIL$B!'(Bsamaki@hs.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp                       
$B"#J;G$!'Cf3X9;(B/$BK!@/Bg9)3XIt(B($BM}2J650i(B)/$B5\>k650iBg(B($B3X9;NW>2(B) $B!!(B

Id: #a19981121031740$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 03:17:40 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981114023546
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: $B%=!<%+%k;a$d:84,;a$X$NBP1~$N;EJ}$K$D$$$F(B

$B;d$,%=!<%+%k;v7o0J8e$NO@Ah$N%j%s%/=8$r:n$C$F$$$F$+$J$j5$$K$J$C$?$3$H$O!"9-$$0UL#$G$N2J3XO@%W%m%Q!<$N?MC#$O<+J,C#$,8l$C$F$$$k$3$H$,B>$N>l=j$G$I$N$h$&$K;H$o$l$F$$$k$+!"$b$7$/$O!"$I$N$h$&$K;H$o$l$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$+!"$K$D$$$F$I$&9M$($F$$$k$+$K$D$$$F$J$N$@!#(B

$B>/$J$/$H$b!"%/!<%s$H%]%Q!<3XGI$NO@Ah$r(B I. Lakatos and A. Musgrave (eds.): Criticism and the growth of knowledge, Cambridge U.P., 1970 ($B?9Gn4FLu(B: $BHcH=$HCN<1$N@.D9!"LZBx

$B5-21$KMj$C$F=q$/$N$G@53N$G$O$J$$$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$,!"%/!<%s<+?H$,<+J,<+?H$N8@MU$N2rIU$1$F5DO@$7$F$$$k$7!"%U%!%$%d%"!<%Y%s%H$O!"%/!<%s$,$I$&H]Dj$7$h$&$HCN$j9g$$$N!"$F$J967b$r;E3]$1$F$$$^$9!#$H$K$+$/!"2J3XE/3X$,B>$G$I$N$h$&$KMxMQ$5$l$F$$$k$+!"$,LdBj$K$5$l$F$$$?$N$G$9!#$=$7$F!"8e$K%/!<%s$H%U%!%$%d%"!<%Y%s%H$O6&$K%V%k%"$d%P!<%s%:C#$N2J3XCN<1$N

$B%=!<%+%k$5$s$d:84,$5$s$N$h$&$JN)>l$+$i$N2J3XO@$X$NHcH=$O!"N.9T$N2J3XO@$NB>$G$N1F6A(B($B$b$7$/$O$=$N2DG=@-(B)$B$r9MN8$7$?>e$G!9$J$I$K$D$$$F!"$b$N$9$4$/$3$@$o$C$?BP1~$N;EJ}$r$7$F$$$k$N$G$9$,!";DG0$J$,$i!"$=$N$h$&$JBP1~$N;EJ}$OA4$/E*30$l$@$H;W$&!#$7$+$b!"B?$/$N>l9g$K$*$$$F!"$=$NBP1~$N;EJ}$O!V2f!9$,$d$C$F$$$k$3$H$r$"$$$D$i$OM}2r$7$F$J$$$+$iJ86g$r8@$&$N$@!W$H$$$&BVEY$,8+$(1#$l$7$F$$$k$H46$8$k$N$O;d$@$1$G$7$g$&$+!)!!$=$&$$$&@lLg2H$NFC8"E*N)>l$KN)$C$?BP1~$N;EJ}$G$OBLL\$J$N$G$9!#$=$N$h$&$JBP1~$N;EJ}$G$OBLL\$@$H$$$&$3$H$O!"2J3XO@%W%m%Q!<$,2J3X$N@lLg2H$K4X$7$F6/D4$9$k$H$3$m$N!V>o<1!W$N0l$D$G$9$h$M!#(B

$B!X8=Be;WA[!Y;o$KK.Lu$5$l$?(B$B%=!<%+%k;a$NO@@b(B$B$rFI$`$H!"2J3X$NScientific American $B$K:\$C$?5-;v(B$B$K$O%=!<%+%k;a$,

If you press them on that, they might come up with 'Oh, what I really meant is not the radical thing it seems to mean, but what I really meant was blah blah blah,' where blah blah blah is something that's not only not radical at all, it's true and trivial.

$B%/!<%s$H%]%Q!<3XGI$NO@Ah$b$3$NN`$N$b$N$G$"$k$H8@$C$FNI$$$H;W$$$^$9!#$9$J$o$A!"%/!<%s$N!X2J3X3WL?$N9=B$!Y$O[#Kf$GBg76:@$JI=8=$,B??t;H$o$l$F$$$F!"$=$l$,$"$k

$B$3$3$^$G2!$5$($?>e$G!"2J3X$NR2p$5$l$F$$$k$+!"$K$D$$$F6=L#$r;}$C$FD4$Y$?$H$7$^$9!#(B$B$3$l(B$B$rFI$s$G$_$F2<$5$$!#FC$K8eH>ItJ,$H:G8e$N$-$a$NJ86g$KCmL\$7$^$7$g$&!#$3$l$K4X$7$F!"3'$5$s$O$I$N$h$&$J46A[$r$*;}$A$G$7$g$&$+!)(B

$B;d$O$3$l$K4X$7$F%=!<%+%k;a$NN)>l$r;Y;}$7$F$$$^$9!#MM!9$JFI


P.S. $BIMED$5$s$,>R2p$5$l$F$$$?2J3X;K(BML$B$K$*$1$k(B$BLn2H$5$sK\?M$K$h$k:84,$5$s$X$N2sEz(B$B$,(B$BM}2J650i(BML$B$K5v2D$rF@$?>e$GE>:\$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B


Id: #a19981121030433$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Sat Nov 21 03:04:33 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981120102412
Name: YAMANE Shinji
Subject: $BM}2J650i$H%5%$%(%s%9!&%&%)!<%:;K4Q(B

$B:84,$5$s$NM}2J650iSocial Text$B;v7o$G$bF1MM$NLdBj$,$"$k$H;W$$$^$7$?!#(B

Social Text$B$N(B Andrew Ross $B$O!"Cx=q(BStrange Weather$B$NKAF,$K$3$&=q$$$F$$$^$9!#(B

This book is dedicated to all of the science teachers I never had. It could only have been written without them.
$B$3$3$GH`$O$^$5$K<+J,$NC&Cf?4E*$J2J3XO@$,3X9;650i$G65$($i$l$k$3$H$r4k?^$7$F$$$k$o$1$G$9!#(BRoss$B$rHcH=$9$kJ8>O$N$$$/$D$+$O!"$3$NJ8>O$rLdBj$K$7$F$$$^$9$7!";d$b(BRoss$B$O:$$C$??M$@$H;W$&!#(B
$B;d$,:$$k$N$O!"$?$H$($P(B Strange Weather $B$N The existence of a ghostbustering organization like CSICOP is as much a symptom of the crisis in scientific rationality and materialism as it is a grudging acknowledgment of New Age's resurgent interest in the minority non-rationalist traditions of Euro-American culture.
$B$D$^$j!"(BCSICOP$B$,5?;w2J3X$rHcH=$9$k$N$OH`$i$,4m5!$K4Y$C$F$$$k$3$H$N>I8u$G$"$j!"%K%e!<%(%$%82J3X$O$=$N?M3J>c32$N$$$1$K$($H$7$F!VKb=w@b8!>Z$r$7$F$b$7$J$/$F$b5?;w2J3X$O>o$K@5$7$$!#$3$l$O%]%Q!<0JA0$NAGKQ$J$Z$F$s$G$9!#$3$l$r3X9;65;U$K65$($5$;$F$I$&$7$h$&$H$$$&$N$G$7$g$&$+!#(B
$B2J3XO@e$N$h$&$JJ*8@$$$rA[Dj$7$F$$$k$H8+$k$Y$-$G$7$g$&!#(B
[$B$J$*!"(BCSICOP$B$K$D$$$F$OBgF&@8ED$5$sLu$N(B sci.skeptic FAQ( http://www.icsd2.tj.chiba-u.ac.jp/mame/SKEP_FAQ/skeptic.html)$B$,JXMx$G$9!#(B]

$B $B@$O@$K$*$1$kL>@<$NAS<:$d8xE*M=;;$+$i$N;q6b6!5k$NDc2<$r@bL@$9$k$?$a$K(B $B!"2J3X$K$*$1$kJ] $B$H$$$&H?F0$r7b$D$Y$/$K4k2h$5$l$F$$$^$9$,!"(B $B$3$l$ODI$$5M$a$i$l$?2J3X $B$3$&$$$&$3$H$r=q$/$H!";d$bKb=w


Id: #a19981120232310$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Fri Nov 20 23:23:10 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981118082829
Name: $B$/$m$-(B $B$2$s(B
Subject: $B?tM}O@M}3X$N652J=q(B

$B$&$A$N3X@8$O!"(B$BEDCf0lG7(B$BJTCx!&(B$B$B!&(B$B3QEDK!Li(B$B!&(B$B5FCS@?(B$B6&Cx!X(B$B?t3X4pACO@9V5A(B$B!Y(B($BF|K\I>O@$bFI$s$G$$$k!#(B)$B!!EDCf$5$s$K$h$k!V(B$B?t3X4pACO@$N3X$SJ}(B$B!W$b%&%'%V>e$GFI$a$k$N$@!#(B

($B$?$^$C$?%a!<%k$N=hM}$,BgJQ$J$N$@!#(B)


Id: #a19981120141409$B!!(B (reply, thread)
Date: Fri Nov 20 14:14:09 1998
In-Reply-To: a0028.html#a19981116035633
URL: samaki@hs.p.u-tokyo.ac.jp
Name: $B:84,7rCK(B
Subject: $B!VCg4V!W$NDHED29CH2=O@HcH=(B
$B!!:84,7rCK$G$9!#(B
$B!!!X>p67!Y#9#8!%#47n9f$O!V4D6-LdBj$X$N;k3Q!WFC=8$G$7$?$N$GGc$$$^$7$?!#(B
$B!!$=$3$K2O5\?.O:!'H?!V29CH2=!W$N7P:Q3X$H$$$&O@@b$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B!!4{B8$NH?!V29CH2=!WO@$r@0M}$7$F$"$j!"$\$/$K$OLr$KN)$A$^$7$?!#(B
$B!!$=$NCf$KDHED$5$s$NO@$K8@5Z$7$F$$$kItJ,$,$"$j$^$9!#6&$K%(%s%H%m%T!<(B
$B3X2q$NO@5R!J2O5\$5$s$O3N$+6p>l$N<+<#2q0Q0wD9$@$C$?$h$&$J!#$\$/$O6p>l(B
$B$8$c$J$$$G$9$h!K$8$c$J$+$C$?$C$1!)(B
$B!!2O5\$5$s$O8@$$$^$9!#(B
$B!t$J$*29CH2=O@$N@99T$r$h$=$K29CH2=O@$r$^$H$b$KH]Dj$9$k5DO@$b$"$k!#$?(B
$B$H$($PDHEDFX$O:G6aCx!X%(%3%m%8!Z$7$J$$$3$H$KCm(B
$B0U!K!#ET;T9)6HJ8L@$X$N1T$$HcH=\$7$/H?O@$9$k$3$H$O$7$J$$!#$7$+$7!VC:;@%,%929CH2=A{F0!W$O!"(B
$B86H/?d?J$N%-%c%s%Z!<%s!W$@$H$$$&DHED$N5DO@$N!V@5$7$5!W$O!"!VJF9q@PC:(B
$B6H3&$r%9%]%s%5!<$K$9$k3X-Mh$N0l

1$B$DA0$N5-O?!'(B$B9uLZ$N$J$s$G$b7G<(HD(B (0028)


$B4IM}kuroki@math.tohoku.ac.jp
> $B!!(B(Web Site)